Skip to content
HTML5 Incompatible Browser
Gold Banner

How could gold drop so sharply without an economic explanation?

*Barron's, April 20, 2013

”One potential explanation is that investors have at last recovered their risk appetite and are selling gold to buy equities.  But although that may have been true in the first three months of the year, it was hardly the case on April 15th, the day of gold’s biggest decline, when the S&P 500 dropped as well.

In any case, what would explain this sudden optimism?  Some investors believe that America grew robustly in the first quarter but the latest data — from unemployment and retail sales to consumer confidence and the purchasing managers’ survey of manufacturing — have been disappointing.  The same is true of other parts of the world, including China, where first-quarter growth was below expectations, and Germany, where the ZEW survey of economic sentiment fell sharply in April.  The IMF lowered its global-growth forecast for the year on April 16th.

Commodity prices in general have been suffering, not something you would expect if investors believed that the world economy was rebounding.  The price of a barrel of Brent crude oil has fallen by 10.6% so far this year.  Copper, often seen as a bellwether of global activity, has dropped by 8%.

Furthermore, if economic sentiment were improving significantly, you would expect investors to sell government bonds as well as gold.  But the ten-year Treasury-bond yield has fallen by more than a third of a percentage point since March 11th.  The latest survey of fund managers by Bank of America Merrill Lynch shows that they have become less optimistic about growth in recent months, and have increased their holdings of cash.

Another potential explanation for gold’s fall is linked to central-bank policy.  The most recent set of Federal Reserve minutes suggested that the pace of quantitative easing (QE), the creation of money to buy assets, would slow later this year.  Many of the most enthusiastic buyers of gold believed that QE would ultimately lead to rapid consumer inflation.  So far that has not come to pass: expectations for American inflation over the next ten years, as measured by the difference between the yields on normal and inflation-protected bonds, dropped to 2.4% on April 16th, the lowest level since November.  If QE is tapering off and inflation is low, the case for buying gold is weaker.

Yet the obituaries of QE seem premature.  First, the Fed has said in the past that the policy is likely to continue until the outlook for jobs improves substantially.  Given the recent turn for the worse in economic data, which occurred after the Fed’s last policy meeting, that point still seems a long way off.  Second, the Bank of Japan has just unveiled a highly aggressive form of QE.  With the yen declining in response, many analysts have been talking about a Japanese liquidity boost for the world.  That ought to make gold bugs salivate.

In short, it is hard to find a rationale in the current economic outlook that would simultaneously send gold and bond yields down, and stock markets up.  Perhaps investors are simply as confused as Lukas Podolski, a German football player who described the game as ‘like chess, only without the dice.’

The usual explanation for sharp price movements, when an economic rationale seems lacking, is that someone is selling off their holdings at any price.”

*This information is solely a highlight of the opinion of a third-party publication and is incomplete.  Please subscribe to this publication for the full and timely opinion of the author and call a Monex Account Representative for any additional up-to-date information. This is not an offer to buy or sell precious metals. Investors should obtain advice based on their own individual circumstances and understand the risk before making any investment decision.