Explore Monex
U.S. Budget Deficit
July 1, 2020

Do deficits continue to matter?

“Why deficits matter as much as ever
During normal times, most people grasp what economists call “opportunity cost.” If the government spends money, someone will eventually have to pay the price through higher taxes. During deep recessions, however, there is sometimes a mistaken perception that the old rules no longer apply, and that money can be freely spent without imposing a burden on future generations. Let’s not fall into that trap. It is certainly true that in periods such as the Great Depression, the Great Recession and, yes, today, the cost of government borrowing is much lower than usual — even close to zero. But these debts will persist, and when interest rates eventually increase, the burden on future taxpayers will also begin to rise.

A substantial portion of the federal debt being issued this year has been purchased by the Federal Reserve. These “open market purchases” of Treasury bonds are the method by which the Fed injects new money into the economy. For various reasons, it probably should buy even more of our debt — perhaps more than 100 percent of the 2020 budget deficit. But the implications of these purchases are not what people who downplay deficits tend to assume. They do not constitute “monetization of the debt,” and certainly don’t relieve us of the burden of the debt. Prior to 2008, Fed purchases of Treasury bonds did indeed represent a monetization of the debt — paying our bills by printing money. This is because the new money created by the Fed during the process, termed the “monetary base,” was essentially a form of cash which did not earn any interest — yet it was used to buy back interest-bearing Treasury debt. Imagine paying off your mortgage with phony dollar bills and you can get a sense of how profitable it is to monetize a public debt.

The profitability of debt monetization means that the Fed has to be very careful. Prior to 2008, it bought relatively little public debt each year in order to hold inflation down. Countries that aggressively monetized their debt, such as Zimbabwe and Venezuela, ended up with hyperinflation. After the Great Recession struck in 2008, however, the Fed adjusted its approach to monetary policy by paying interest on the reserves banks have deposited at the Fed. This encourages banks to hold on to more reserves rather than lending the money out. It changed everything. Because Fed “quantitative easing” programs now mostly involve exchanging interest-bearing bank reserves – not zero-interest currency – for interest-bearing Treasury debt, this form of money creation is no longer as profitable. And because most of the new money created by the Fed is interest-bearing reserves, it is no longer highly inflationary.

While currency issuance is still profitable for the government in 2020, by itself this covers only a tiny portion of our budget deficit. Most newly created money is now merely another form of federal government debt. Right now, the interest rate paid on bank reserves is only slightly above zero. But as we saw in the latter part of the past decade, interest rates generally rise when the economy recovers. Thus, all the bank reserves currently being injected into the economy will eventually have to be neutralized in one of two ways: First, the Fed could withdraw the excess reserves from circulation as market rates rise by selling off Treasury bonds. Alternatively, it could increase the interest rate it pays on bank reserves to track market rates. If it chose neither option, then we’d have true “debt monetization,” but also risk ending up with hyperinflation.”

*This information is solely an excerpt of a third-party publication and is incomplete. Please subscribe to the referenced publication for the full article. This is not an offer to buy or sell precious metals. Investors should obtain advice based on their own individual circumstances and understand the risk before making any investment decision.

See What Investors are Saying About Monex

Thank You!
Want your kit sooner?
Faster delivery is available by phone.
Get Your Free Report

A New Decade for
Precious Metals Investing

  • All form fields are required

  • Privacy Policy
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Download Your Report